Advocacy International: Advancing the Digital Rights Agenda for Asia, 2021
Advocacy International is an opportunity for young digital rights defenders from Asia to strengthen their skills on policy advocacy in international spaces for advancing digital rights.
- Workshop Overview
- Agenda
- Zoom links to workshop and instructions to use Zoom
- Sessions' briefer for participants
- Reading materials for whole workshop
- Read all the summaries here
- Workshop Sessions
- Day 1 | Session 2: Introduction to international advocacy
- Day 1 | Session 3: Stakeholder mapping & understanding the landscape
- Day 2 | Session 4: Treaties, instruments and standards: A baseline for international advocacy
- Day 2 | Session 5: The UN ecosystem: An overview
- Day 2 | Session 6: Engaging with Human Rights mechanisms at the UN
- Day 3 | Session 7: Internet governance & digital cooperation
- Day 3 | Session 8: Telecom & internet infrastructure advocacy
- Day 3 | Session 9: Policy advocacy to policy change: LocNet’s experience on what works
- Day 4 | Session 10: Integrating gender into the global digital rights agenda
- Day 4 | Session 11: Hacking international advocacy: Strategies for effective engagement
- Workshop policies & governing rules
- Resource persons' profiles
- Introduction to international advocacy | Paula Martins
- Stakeholder mapping & understanding the landscape | Verengai Mabika
- Treaties, instruments & standards: A baseline for international advocacy | Sheetal Kumar
- The UN ecosystem: An overview | Deborah Brown
- Engaging with human rights mechanisms at the UN | Sarah Brooks
- Internet governance & digital cooperation | Anriette Esterhuysen
- Telecom & internet infrastructure advocacy | Avri Doria
- Policy advocacy to policy change: LocNet's experience on what works | Carlos Rey Moreno
- Integrating gender into the global digital rights agenda | Pooja Badrinath
- Hacking international advocacy: Strategies for effective engagement | Gayatri Khandhadai
- Organisers Contact Details
- 💥 Online Tools for Workshops and Interactivity
- 🎶 Workshop playlist
Workshop Overview
Agenda
Please check the UTC Time Converter to know the time of the sessions in your local time zone!
🕓 All timings are in UTC AM
Zoom links to workshop and instructions to use Zoom
Our Zoom space
Our workshop will take place at: https://apc-org.zoom.us/j/84919789031
Tips for participation in Zoom sessions
- Update your Zoom client to the latest version. The zoom app takes 5 minutes to install, so please set it up before the sessions.
- Please join the sessions before they start (we have 60 minutes for that), so we can assist you if you experience any issue.
- Please use your real name or nickname, so we can know who you are and let you in. You can change your name after you have joined.
- Please use headphones with microphone rather blue-tooth headphones where possible.
- Please mute your microphone when entering a session and unmute only when you want to speak.
- If you need a break during the sessions, take it.
How to use zoom
Join the workshop session by opening the link [insert link] in your browser, a client or an app. You will be redirected to the correct zoom room with the waiting room. When the host will adds you to the meeting you will be able to see the main screen.
Configure Audio
If your audio is not working, please check your settings.
For Audio click on the up arrow next to Unmute/Mute button and check if your Microphone and Speaker have been correctly configured.
To test Speaker and Microphone click on Audio Settings in the same menu and click on the link Test Speaker and Microphone.
In the window that opens you can Test the Speaker and Microphone and select the volume.
Configure Video
If your video is not working when you click Start Video, please check your settings.
Click on the up arrow next to Start Video and see if Camera is selected.
If you would like to examine settings in more detail, click on the last option Video Settings... and the following window will open.
Here you can define how your video should be presented and we recommend you select the option Hide Non-video Participants so that you will be able to see only the videos of participants who have their cameras enabled.
Chat
Zoom enables you to participate in public chat and also send private messages to specific participants. To send a private message select the participant in the dropdown field which is by default set to Everyone (for public chat).
Share screen...
If you select the wrong window you can always stop sharing and then start sharing the intended one.
Sessions' briefer for participants
Day 1, 29 June 2021:
Session 1: Welcome & check-in
Time: 4:00 - 5:30 UTC
Objective: This session will introduce participants to the workshop and to each other. The aim of the session is to enable participants to get ready and dive into the workshop and help them understand the process or spaces where they will find the information they are looking for.
Session plan:
- Welcome from APC
- Introduction to the event - what the workshop will cover and what it won’t
- Introduction to fellow participants
- Spaces and materials where we can find information
- Logistics for the week
- Rules of engagement
- Opportunities to collaborate in the future
Facilitators: Pavitra Ramanujam & Gayatri Khandhadai
Session 2: Introduction to international advocacy
Time: 6:30 - 8:00 UTC
Objective: This session will introduce discussions for understanding policy advocacy. The aim is to enable participants to understand what international advocacy is and what its limits are. By the end of the session participants will have a better understanding of why policy advocacy is undertaken, where it has succeeded and when it has failed.
Session plan:
- Introduction to international advocacy - what is it?
- Who is it targeted toward?
- The relationship between national and international advocacy
- What have been some examples of successes? (case studies)
- How has the digital era impacted international advocacy spaces?
- What are the challenges one can expect to encounter when engaging in advocacy, especially during the Covid-19 pandemic?
- What are some limitations of international advocacy?
- Case studies of when it has not worked and why.
Resource person: Paula Martins
Session 3: Stakeholder mapping & understanding the landscape
Time: 9:00 - 10:30 UTC
Objective: This session will help participants understand the importance of multistakeholderism and to identify the different stakeholders involved in policy advocacy. By studying the stakeholders and their interests, participants will also be able to understand the actors in the landscape in which they will engage.
Session plan:
- What is multistakeholderism?
- Examples of multi stakeholder processes and progress achieved through them
- Multi Stakeholder vs. Multilateral spaces
- Who are the key stakeholders?
- What are their interests and pressure points?
- How do we engage with the different stakeholders?
Resource person: Verengai Mabika
Day 2, 30 June 2021:
Session 4: Treaties, instruments and standards: A baseline for international advocacy
Time: 4:00 - 5:30 UTC
Objective: This session will introduce participants to key documents that help lay out the standards for digital rights. They form the basis of all forms of international advocacy. Through this session, participants will be equipped with knowledge on the types of instruments and standards they set out as the basis for advocating for change.
Session plan:
- Kinds of instruments that set out the standards for digital rights:
-
- Instruments and their enforceability (treaties, declarations, resolutions and general comments)
- Other documents (ex. Universal Periodic Review (UPR) reports, UN Special Rapporteur reports and Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) reports)
- Instruments to use:
- Digital rights - Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), International Covenant for Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), International Covenant for Economic Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), Rabat Plan of Action
- Gender rights - Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimmination Against Women (CEDAW)
- Infrastructure - International Telecommunications Union (ITU) documentation, ICESCR (right to scientific development)
- Soft standards for specific issues
Resource person: Sheetal Kumar
Session 5: The UN ecosystem: An overview
Time: 6:30 - 8:00 UTC
Objective: This session will provide an overview of the different spaces available in the UN ecosystem. Understanding these spaces will help the participants identify spaces where they want to advocate on digital rights. Through looking at examples of important standards these spaces have created or instances of success, participants will be aided in modelling their advocacy. Limitations or failures of these spaces will help us understand areas that need more work.
Session plan:
- UN ecosystem
- General Assembly (GA)
- Internet Governance Forum (IGF )
- International Telecommunications Union (ITU)
- Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
- Gender - Commission on the Status of Women (CSW)
- World Trade Organisation (WTO)
- Which spaces can you be at?
- UN interaction with regional bodies and other institutions (like the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)) - upcoming sessions
- Successes for the digital rights movement at the UN
- Challenges in engaging with these spaces
Resource person: Deborah Brown
Session 6: Engaging with Human Rights mechanisms at the UN
Time: 9:00 - 10:30 UTC
Objective: In continuation of the previous session, this session will focus on human rights spaces in the UN ecosystem. By enabling participants to understand the human rights spaces in the UN, the session will help them gear up for targeted advocacy. Discussion on effective engagement in each of these unique processes will be undertaken through looking at specific examples of cases and the array of types of interventions possible.
Session plan:
- Treaty bodies
- What are the relevant treaty bodies and what can they do?
Submissions and advocacy with treaty bodies - Human Rights Council (HRC)
- Sessions at the HRC and what can we do?
- UPR and how to engage?
- Special Procedures
- OHCHR
- Their engagement with digital rights
- What kind of interventions can you make?
- Participation in negotiation of norms (resolutions)
- Statements - written and oral
- Bilateral meetings
- Side-events
- Submissions and shadow reports to UNSR, UPR, TBs
Resource person: Sarah Brooks
Day 3, 1 July 2021:
Session 7: Internet governance & digital cooperation
Time: 4:00 - 5:30 UTC
Objective: This session will build on the discussions around multistakeholderism and look at how internet governance spaces can be used for advocacy. Specific emphasis will be given to the Roadmap For Digital Cooperation process and the Internet Governance Forum. Effective ways to engage in these processes will help participants identify where they can place themselves to advocate.
Session plan:
- Road map for digital cooperation
- What is the Roadmap and what are the key areas it covers?
- How and why was it created?
- How is it being implemented?
- Internet Governance Forum (IGF)
- What is the IGF?
- How to engage in the IGF and how can we shape the agenda?
- Inter-sessional work at the IGF through Best Practice Forums (BPF) and Dynamic Coalitions (DC)
- Asia Pacific Regional IGF (APrIGF), sub-regional IGFs and national IGFs - their relationship
- Reflection about the IGF, future and how to strengthen it?
Resource person: Anriette Esterhuysen
Session 8: Telecom & internet infrastructure advocacy
Time: 6:30 - 8:00 UTC
Objective:This session will help us understand global technical and telecommunication spaces. These spaces are critical for standard setting and cooperation, by understanding how they function participants will be able to develop skills around engaging them. Looking at the limitations these spaces have and the challenges that civil society has faced in working with them will help us identify areas that need more attention.
Session plan:
- What technical and telecommunication spaces are available for advocacy and what do they focus on?
- Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN)
- Asia Pacific Network Information Centre (APNIC)
- Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF)
- Internet Telecommunications Union (ITU)
- World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS)
- Global Symposium for Regulators
- Global Network Initiative (GNI)
- What is possible in these spaces?
- Who can engage in these spaces?
- How to engage with the technical community?
- Technical skills - is it a must?
- What are the limitations or challenges faced in engaging these spaces?
Resource person: Avri Doria
Session 9: Policy advocacy to policy change: LocNet’s experience on what works
Time: 9:00 - 10:30 UTC
Objective: This session is tailored to understand practical developments seen through consistent policy advocacy in telecommunication spaces. This is done by looking at how the LocNet initiative worked on regulatory frameworks on community networks in international spaces. Participants will be engaged in discussions around elements behind a long-term policy advocacy strategy that is starting to create tangible policy change for community networks.
Session plan:
- What is LocNet and what are community networks?
- How and why did LocNet start and are progressing on policy work especially on technical regulatory work
- Working with telecommunication regulators
- What are the different areas of work for Policy Advocacy in LocNet?
- Rationale behind them
- Objectives
- Results obtained thus far
- Lessons learned
- What are the advocacy spaces at the international level for telecom policy?
- What have been the most successful changes and what are the challenges?
- Next steps and feedback to make it work in Asia
Resource person: Carlos Rey Moreno
Day 4, 2 July 2021:
Session 10: Integrating gender into the global digital rights agenda
Time: 4:00 - 5:30 UTC
Objective: This session will work towards helping participants understand and develop gender perspectives to policy advocacy. While the session will address gender specific advocacy spaces, it will also introduce ways to incorporate gender perspectives and experiences in other advocacy initiatives. The successes, especially what it took to get there and challenges or limitations will help the participants shape and influence their initiatives in the future.
Session plan:
- Why does gender matter in digital rights policy advocacy?
- Importance of linking women’s rights advocacy to digital rights advocacy (language, issues, intersectionality and allyship)
- Thematic issues (eg surveillance, access, sexuality, online gender based violence (GBV), expression and association)
- Challenges and opportunities of ‘doing gender’ in digital rights advocacy
- Actors / allies / networks for engaging in advocacy
- Spaces (eg CEDAW and others)
- Example of successful advocacy - Case study on online gender based violence and the 10 years of advocacy (and multi-pronged strategy) it took to get the resolution on violence against women and girls in a digital age
- How can we incorporate gender perspectives in all policy advocacy initiatives?
Resource person: Pooja Badrinath
Session 11: Hacking international advocacy: Strategies for effective engagement
Time: 6:30 - 8:00 UTC
Objective: This session will tie up all the discussions in the previous days and move towards developing key strategies to engage in advocacy. In this practice based session, the participants will be looking at elements involved in developing responsive strategies for engaging in effective international advocacy. Moving from strategy, the session will also discuss building networks and identifying key components of different documents to be prepared for advocacy.
Session plan:
- Why is it necessary to develop a strategy for international advocacy?
- What are the key elements that a strategy must hold?
- What kinds of documentation would be necessary to engage in international advocacy?
- Elements for written submissions, policy briefers and statements
- Who are the actors that we can reach out to for support and networking?
- Communication and campaigning in international advocacy
Resource person: Gayatri Khandhadai
Reading materials for whole workshop
Reading materials for all sessions
Read all the summaries here
Workshop Sessions
Day 1 | Session 2: Introduction to international advocacy
Tuesday, 29 June, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Objective: This session will introduce discussions for understanding policy advocacy. The aim is to enable participants to understand what international advocacy is and what its limits are. By the end of the session participants will have a better understanding of why policy advocacy is undertaken, where it has succeeded and when it has failed.
Session plan:
- Introduction to international advocacy - what is it?
- Who is it targeted toward?
- The relationship between national and international advocacy
- What have been some examples of successes? (case studies)
- How has the digital era impacted international advocacy spaces?
- What are the challenges one can expect to encounter when engaging in advocacy, especially during the Covid-19 pandemic?
- What are some limitations of international advocacy?
- Case studies of when it has not worked and why
*Reading materials and tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- Eóin Young & Lisa Quinn, Making Research Evidence Matter: A Guide to Policy Advocacy in Transition Countries
- ISHR Academy, Risks in Engaging with the UN
Additional Readings
- APC, APC Internet Rights Charter
- Johanna Eve Simeant, Interpreting the Rise of International “Advocacy”
Representations:
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 1 Summary Here
Day 1 | Session 3: Stakeholder mapping & understanding the landscape
Tuesday, 29 June, 2021 [9:00 - 10:30 UTC]
Objective: This session will help participants understand the importance of multistakeholderism and to identify the different stakeholders involved in policy advocacy. By studying the stakeholders and their interests, participants will also be able to understand the actors in the landscape in which they will engage.
Session plan:
- What is multistakeholderism?
- Examples of multi stakeholder processes and progress achieved through them
- Multi Stakeholder vs. Multilateral spaces
- Who are the key stakeholders?
- What are their interests and pressure points?
- How do we engage with the different stakeholders?
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- APC, Frequently asked questions about multi-stakeholder partnerships in ICTs for development: A guide for national ICT policy animators
- EvalPartners, Stakeholder analysis in advocacy
- Save the Children, Advocacy Targets
Additional Readings
- APC, Inside the Information Society The what and why of multistakeholder participation
- APC, Inside the Information Society: Multistakeholder participation, a work in progress
- The Transnational Institute, Where we are now with the emergence of multistakeholderism
Representations:
- Mapping Stakeholders Communities
- Multi Stakeholder Model
- Benefits and Challenges of Multistakeholderism
- Advocacy Targets
- Multistakeholderism and the deliberative process
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 1 Summary Here
Day 2 | Session 4: Treaties, instruments and standards: A baseline for international advocacy
Wednesday, 30 June, 2021 [4:00 - 5:30 UTC]
Objective: This session will introduce participants to key documents that help lay out the standards for digital rights. They form the basis of all forms of international advocacy. Through this session, participants will be equipped with knowledge on the types of instruments and standards they set out as the basis for advocating for change.
Session plan:
- Kinds of instruments that set out the standards for digital rights:
- Instruments and their enforceability (treaties, declarations, resolutions and general comments)
- Other documents (ex. Universal Periodic Review (UPR) reports, UN Special Rapporteur reports and Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) reports)
- Instruments to use:
- Digital rights - Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), International Covenant for Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), International Covenant for Economic Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR), Rabat Plan of Action
- Gender rights - Convention on the Elimination of all forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW)
- Infrastructure - International Telecommunications Union (ITU) documentation, ICESCR (right to scientific development)
- Soft standards for specific issues
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- Arturo J. Carrillo, Primer on Researching International Law to Advance Digital Rights
- Council of Europe, Legal Protection of Human Rights
- Global Information Society Watch, Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and the Internet
- APC, Inside the Information Society: Connecting ICTs to economic, social and cultural rights
Additional Readings
- Article 19, Freedom of expression and ICTs: Overview of international standards
- Global Network Initiative, Digital Freedoms in International Law: Practical Steps to protect Human Rights Online
- The Danish Institute for Human Rights, ICT and Human Rights
- The Rise of International Advocacy
Representations:
- Human Rights Instruments
- Status of Ratification
- UDHR
- UDHR Memory Aid
- Bill of Rights
- Reporting Cycle under Human Rights Treaties
- The Impact of the Internet on Human Rights in Africa
- The International State of Digital Rights, a Conversation with the UN Special Rapporteur
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 2 Summary Here
Day 2 | Session 5: The UN ecosystem: An overview
Wednesday, 30 June, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Objective: This session will provide an overview of the different spaces available in the UN ecosystem. Understanding these spaces will help the participants identify spaces where they want to advocate on digital rights. Through looking at examples of important standards these spaces have created or instances of success, participants will be aided in modelling their advocacy. Limitations or failures of these spaces will help us understand areas that need more work.
- UN ecosystem
- General Assembly (GA)
- Internet Governance Forum (IGF )
- International Telecommunications Union (ITU)
- Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
- Gender - Commission on the Status of Women (CSW)
- World Trade Organisation (WTO)
- Which spaces can you be at?
- UN interaction with regional bodies and other institutions (like the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD)) - upcoming sessions
- Successes for the digital rights movement at the UN
- Challenges in engaging with these spaces
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
- United Nations, The United Nations System
- Advocates for Human Rights, Advocacy at the United Nations
- International Telecommunication Union, ICTs in Support of Human Rights, Democracy and Good Governance
- Sheetal Kumar and Deborah Brown, UN First Committee Process on Responsible State Behaviour in Cyberspace: An Explainer
- International Service for Human Rights, Third Committee of the United Nations General Assembly: A Practical Guide for NGOs
- Lisa Cornish, Engaging private sector within the UN framework: What are the challenges?
- UN Women, What is International Human Rights Advocacy?
Representations:
- Reporting cycle under Human Rights treaties
- ICT Related Recommendations of the High-Level Review on UN Sanctions
- Mapping International ICT Decision Making
- United Nations System: Explainer
- Navigating the UN
- UN Spaces for Advocacy
Exercise:
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 2 Summary Here
Day 2 | Session 6: Engaging with Human Rights mechanisms at the UN
Wednesday, 30 June, 2021 [9:00 - 10:30 UTC]
Objective: In continuation of the previous session, this session will focus on human rights spaces in the UN ecosystem. By enabling participants to understand the human rights spaces in the UN, the session will help them gear up for targeted advocacy. Discussion on effective engagement in each of these unique processes will be undertaken through looking at specific examples of cases and the array of types of interventions possible.
Session plan:
- Treaty bodies
- What are the relevant treaty bodies and what can they do?
Submissions and advocacy with treaty bodies - Human Rights Council (HRC)
- Sessions at the HRC and what can we do?
- UPR and how to engage?
- Special Procedures
- OHCHR
- Their engagement with digital rights
- What kind of interventions can you make?
- Participation in negotiation of norms (resolutions)
- Statements - written and oral
- Bilateral meetings
- Side-events
- Submissions and shadow reports to UNSR, UPR, TBs
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- International Service for Human Rights, A Simple Guide to the UN Treaty Bodies
- Deborah Brown & Sheetal Kumar, A guide to help human rights defenders navigate the Universal Periodic Review
- United Nations Human Rights Council, A practical guide for NGOs
- Open Society Institute, UN Treaty Committees
Additional Readings
- UN OHCHR, How to Follow Up on United Nations Human Rights Recommendations
- United Nations Development Programme, Strengthening Engagement with the International Human Rights Machinery: A Practioner’s Guide
- UN OHCHR, Universal Human Rights Index
- UN OHCHR, Training Manual on Human Rights Monitoring
- UN OHCHR, A Practical Guide to Effective State Engagement with International Human Rights Mechanisms
- APC & Advocacy Assembly, Making an Impact with the Universal Periodic Review
Representations:
- Map of UNHRC Spaces
- Human Rights Architecture
- Introduction to Human Rights Treaties
- Human Rights Treaty System
- State Party Reporting Obligations under International Human Rights Treaties
- Human Rights Mechanism
- UN Human Rights Organizational Chart
- UNHRC 47th Session: 'How To' Guide
- UNHRC Members who have sponsored or co-sponsored Resolutions on the promotion, protection and enjoyment of human rights on the Internet
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 2 Summary Here
Day 3 | Session 7: Internet governance & digital cooperation
Thursday, 1 July, 2021 [4:00 - 5:30 UTC]
Objective: This session will build on the discussions around multistakeholderism and look at how internet governance spaces can be used for advocacy. Specific emphasis will be given to the Roadmap For Digital Cooperation process and the Internet Governance Forum. Effective ways to engage in these processes will help participants identify where they can place themselves to advocate.
Session plan:
- Road map for digital cooperation
- What is the Roadmap and what are the key areas it covers?
- How and why was it created?
- How is it being implemented?
- Internet Governance Forum (IGF)
- What is the IGF?
- How to engage in the IGF and how can we shape the agenda?
- Inter-sessional work at the IGF through Best Practice Forums (BPF) and Dynamic Coalitions (DC)
- Asia Pacific Regional IGF (APrIGF), sub-regional IGFs and national IGFs - their relationship
- Reflection about the IGF, future and how to strengthen it?
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- Internet Governance Forum, Evolution of the Internet Governance Ecosystem and Role of the IGF
- United Nations, High Level Panel on Digital Cooperation
- DigWatch, Overview of the IGF
Additional Readings
- Internet Society, Internet Governance: Why the Multistakeholder Approach Works
- UNESCO, What if we all governed the Internet? Advancing multistakeholder participation in Internet governance
- Internet Governance Forum. Regional IGFs and their initiatives
Representations:
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 3 Summary Here
Day 3 | Session 8: Telecom & internet infrastructure advocacy
Thursday, 1 July, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Objective:This session will help us understand global technical and telecommunication spaces. These spaces are critical for standard setting and cooperation, by understanding how they function participants will be able to develop skills around engaging them. Looking at the limitations these spaces have and the challenges that civil society has faced in working with them will help us identify areas that need more attention.
Session plan:
- What technical and telecommunication spaces are available for advocacy and what do they focus on?
- Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN)
- Asia Pacific Network Information Centre (APNIC)
- Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF)
- Internet Telecommunications Union (ITU)
- World Summit on the Information Society (WSIS)
- Global Symposium for Regulators
- Global Network Initiative (GNI)
- What is possible in these spaces?
- Who can engage in these spaces?
- How to engage with the technical community?
- Technical skills - is it a must?
- What are the limitations or challenges faced in engaging these spaces?
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- Joy Liddicoat and Avri Doria, Human rights and Internet protocols: Comparing processes and principle
- LocNet, Engagement at International Telecommunication Union processes
- ICANN, Introduction to ICANN
- IETF, Getting started in the ITEF
Additional Readings
- Global Network Initiative, Principles on Freedom of Expression and Privacy
- Global Network Initiative, Implementation Guidelines for the Principles on Freedom of Expression and Privacy
Representations:
- Technical and Telecommunications Spaces
- Dimensions for mapping internet governance issues and entities
- ICANN and the internet ecosystem
- Introduction to ICANN
- Internet Ecosystem: Asia Pacific
- Internet Ecosystem: Global Perspective
- Internet Governance Timeline
- Internet Organization
- Who Runs the Internet?
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 3 Summary Here
Day 3 | Session 9: Policy advocacy to policy change: LocNet’s experience on what works
Thursday, 1 July, 2021 [9:00 - 10:30 UTC]
Objective: This session is tailored to understand practical developments seen through consistent policy advocacy in telecommunication spaces. This is done by looking at how the LocNet initiative worked on regulatory frameworks on community networks in international spaces. Participants will be engaged in discussions around elements behind a long-term policy advocacy strategy that is starting to create tangible policy change for community networks.
Session plan:
- What is LocNet and what are community networks?
- How and why did LocNet start and are progressing on policy work especially on technical regulatory work
- Working with telecommunication regulators
- What are the different areas of work for Policy Advocacy in LocNet?
- Rationale behind them
- Objectives
- Results obtained thus far
- Lessons learned
- What are the advocacy spaces at the international level for telecom policy?
- What have been the most successful changes and what are the challenges?
- Next steps and feedback to make it work in Asia
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- APC, Expanding the telecommunications operators ecosystem: Policy and regulatory guidelines to enable local operators
- LocNet, Policy and Regulation for Community Networks
- LocNet, Engagement at International Telecommunication Union processes
- Internet Society, Telecommunications Reclaimed: A Hands On Guide to Networking Communities
Additional Readings
- APC, Mapping the Regulatory Environment of Community Networks in India, Myanmar & Philippines
- UNESCAP, Digital connectivity and e-resilience as a foundation infrastructure: perspectives during COVID-19
- UNESCAP, In-Depth Study of the Asia-Pacific Information Superhighway in CLMV Countries: Asia-Pacific Information Superhighway (AP-IS) Working Paper Series
- UNESCAP, Master Plan for the Asia-Pacific Information Superhighway, 2019-2022
Representations:
- AP-IS Master Plan Initiatives
- Community Networks
- Internet Society, Community Networks 101
- Four Pillars of Asia Pacific Superhighway
- ITU AP-IS Interactive Map
- LocNet Country Profiles
🔖 Read Day 3 Summary Here
Day 4 | Session 10: Integrating gender into the global digital rights agenda
Friday, 2 July, 2021 [4:00 - 5:30 UTC]
Objective: This session will work towards helping participants understand and develop gender perspectives to policy advocacy. While the session will address gender specific advocacy spaces, it will also introduce ways to incorporate gender perspectives and experiences in other advocacy initiatives. The successes, especially what it took to get there and challenges or limitations will help the participants shape and influence their initiatives in the future.
Session plan:
- Why does gender matter in digital rights policy advocacy?
- Importance of linking women’s rights advocacy to digital rights advocacy (language, issues, intersectionality and allyship)
- Thematic issues (eg surveillance, access, sexuality, online gender based violence (GBV), expression and association)
- Challenges and opportunities of ‘doing gender’ in digital rights advocacy
- Actors / allies / networks for engaging in advocacy
- Spaces (eg CEDAW and others)
- Example of successful advocacy - Case study on online gender based violence and the 10 years of advocacy (and multi-pronged strategy) it took to get the resolution on violence against women and girls in a digital age
- How can we incorporate gender perspectives in all policy advocacy initiatives?
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- Feminist Internet, Feminist Principles of the Internet
- NGO CSW/NY, A Guide for NGOs and Women’s Human Rights Activists at the UN and CSW
- Women Human Rights Defenders International Coalition, A Manual For and About Women Human Rights Defenders
- World Wide Web Foundation, Advancing Women’s Rights Online: Gaps and Opportunities in Policy and Research
Additional Readings
- UN Women, The Digital Revolution: Implications for Gender Equality and Women’s Rights 25 Years after Beijing
- ICRW Reports on Technology Facilitated, Gender Based Violence:
- UN Human Rights Council, Report of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights: Promotion, protection and enjoyment of human rights on the Internet: ways to bridge the gender digital divide from a human rights perspective
- UN Women, UN Gender Laws and Policies
- WHO, on behalf of the United Nations VAW-IAWGED, Violence Against Women Prevalence Estimate
- Kate Edrinn, Advocacy Tools Dropbox
- OECD, Bridging the Digital Gender Divide
Representations:
- Gender Spaces at the UN
- Gender Based Attitudes Towards Online Violence
- Is the Web Really Empowering Women
- Technology Facilitated Gender Based Violence Explainer
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 4 Summary Here
Day 4 | Session 11: Hacking international advocacy: Strategies for effective engagement
Friday, 2 July, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Objective: This session will tie up all the discussions in the previous days and move towards developing key strategies to engage in advocacy. In this practice based session, the participants will be looking at elements involved in developing responsive strategies for engaging in effective international advocacy. Moving from strategy, the session will also discuss building networks and identifying key components of different documents to be prepared for advocacy.
Session plan:
- Why is it necessary to develop a strategy for international advocacy?
- What are the key elements that a strategy must hold?
- What kinds of documentation would be necessary to engage in international advocacy?
- Elements for written submissions, policy briefers and statements
- Who are the actors that we can reach out to for support and networking?
- Communication and campaigning in international advocacy
*Reading materials and Tables are hyperlinked, please click the text to access
Reading Materials:
Suggested Readings
- APC, Advocacy Strategy and Approaches: Overview
- World Neighbors, A New Weave of Power, People & Politics: The Action Guide for Advocacy and Citizen Participation, Mapping Advocacy Strategies
- The Advocates for Human Rights, A Practitioner's Guide to Human Rights Monitoring, Documentation and Advocacy
Additional Readings
- ISHR Academy, Advocacy Roadmap
- APNIC, Internet governance
- UNICEF, Advocacy Toolkit: Developing an Advocacy Strategy
- World Health Organisation, A practical guide to successful advocacy
- BOND, The How and Why of Advocacy
- Zonta, Gender Based Advocacy
Representations:
- Advocacy Strategies
- A Strategic Approach to Advocacy
- List of Regional and International Groups Dealing with Advocacy
Samples:
- APC, APC at the Human Rights Council 43rd session: Briefing on the deteriorating human rights situation in India
- APC, India’s constitutional and civic space crisis addressed at HRC43 side event
- APC, Written statement by the Association for Progressive Communications on the right to education and the internet
- APC, Human Rights and the Philippine Digital Environment: Joint Submission to the Universal Periodic Review of the Philippines
- APC, Statement at HRC draws attention to draconian and discriminatory measures in Sri Lanka
- APC's submission to the OHCHR, Bridging the gender digital divide from a human rights perspective
📌 Presentation Slide
🔖 Read Day 4 Summary Here
Workshop policies & governing rules
Code of conduct and principles of participation
The Association for Progressive Communications is committed to providing a safe and welcoming environment for discussing issues related to its community. The APC Community comprises members of the network, all APC staff and team and its larger network of partners, friends and allies.
The code of conduct and ground rules apply to this meeting, all APC hosted events, conference-related social events, such as parties or gatherings at restaurants or bars and spaces, and includes our mailing lists, wikis, platforms, websites and any other spaces that APC hosts, both online and off. Participants are responsible for knowing and abiding by these guidelines. In this event, the code applies to anyone who is part of the event, which includes organisers, resource persons, participants and performers.
All APC meetings, virtual and physical meetings, are intended to be SAFE spaces and we ask participants to be guided by the following:
|Be respectful
|Listen actively
|Be respectful of others’ views even when you disagree
|Be collaborative
|Recognise diversity
|Respect privacy of participants
|Ask for consent for photography, audio-visual recordings or quotes
|Be aware of language diversity
|Handle disagreement constructively
|Act fairly, honestly, and in good faith with other participants
It is vital that discussions include and acknowledge a diversity of opinions and experiences, and that the community does not tolerate harassment of any kind.
We expect the members of the APC community to treat one another with respect and to acknowledge that everyone can make a valuable contribution. We may not always agree, but the space and conversation must always have openness to positions that may not be aligned or in agreement. Frustration cannot turn into a personal attack. It's important to remember that a community where people feel uncomfortable or threatened is not a productive one, and that the meeting conduct and ground rules are anchored in the APC values we have all committed to uphold. It is our collective responsibility to ensure that we create a safe, creative, productive and welcoming space that can hold us in all of our diversity.
We will take action in response to harassment related to gender, gender identity and expression, sexual orientation, disability, physical appearance, body size, race, nationality, caste, ethnicity or religion. APC does not tolerate harassment of participants in any form.
Definitions
Harassment
includes, but is not limited to:
- Offensive comments related to gender, gender identity and expression, sexual orientation, disability, mental illness, neuro(a)typicality, physical appearance, body size, race, caste, ethnicity or religion.
- Unwelcome comments regarding a person’s lifestyle choices and practices, including those related to food, health, parenting, drugs, and employment.
- Physical contact and simulated physical contact without consent or after a request to stop.
- Deliberate intimidation.
- Sustained disruption of discussion.
- Continued one-on-one communication after requests to cease.
- Sexual harassment
Sexual harassment
is a broad term. For the purposes of this event it is defined as:
Any unwelcome sexual advance in the form of words, images, gestures or physical contact in physical, digital or communication spaces which may reasonably be expected, or be perceived, to cause distress, intimidation, fear, humiliation, or harm to another. The term also covers any request for a sexual favour, or a threat of a sexual nature. Sexual harassment may occur in any space, including the workplace. This includes activities of face-to-face meetings, virtual meetings and digital communication of all kinds. It can be a one-time incident or a series of incidents. Sexual harassment may be unintended, deliberate, or coercive. Sexual harassment may occur both within formal working hours and spaces, and outside these. Men, women, transitioning and transgender individuals may be victims or offenders.
Sexual harassment may result in discrimination, and it may create a hostile working environment. Other forms of behaviour which cause discrimination, fear, and/or a hostile working environment may be implicated in sexual harassment, such as harassment based on race, gender, sexuality, national origin, physical appearance, age, ancestry, disability, economic disparity, nationality, or religious or spiritual beliefs. APC recognises that APC's staff members, partners and event participants are from diverse contexts, and that sexual harassment experiences are embedded within the cultural, social, historical and personal contexts.
Sexual harassment should not be confused with unintentional careless communication in a diverse working environment, or with our efforts to create a working culture which is open to conversations on sexuality and human rights.
We understand that the impact of sexual harassment on APC's working culture can be highly destructive, and we understand the harmful impact of sexual harassment on any person’s work, mind and body.
Examples of sexual harassment include (but are not limited to):
- Gratuitous or off-topic sexual images or behaviour in spaces where they are not appropriate.
- Unwelcome sharing of sexualised content in visual, audio or text form
- Deliberate stalking, following or intimidation, online and/or offline
- Harassing photography, video or audio recording
- Inappropriate and/or unwanted physical contact
- Unwelcome sexual attention, in any form of communication
- Requests for sexual favours, verbal or physical contact of a sexual nature in exchange for an opportunity
- Threats, either explicit or implicit, to withdraw an opportunity or resources unless sexual contact and/or communication is permitted
- Advocating for, or encouraging, any of the above behaviour.
If you believe you have been harassed, or notice that someone else is being harassed, or have any other concerns, you are encouraged to raise your concerns in confidence to the Event Incidents Team.
APC commits that each case will be considered, and concrete actions will be taken as appropriate.
Please refer to APC’s sexual harassment policy for how APC responds to sexual harassment.
Code of Conduct and Anti-Harassment Policy Response Process
If you are being harassed by a member of the community or a participant or organiser at the conference, or have any other concerns, please contact a member of the Event Incidents Team.
When a complaint is made or an incident occurs that breaches this code, the Event Incidents Team will confidentially review and respond to any participant who has experienced harassment or inappropriate behavior.
If the person who is harassing you is on the Event Incidents Team, they will recuse themselves from handling your incident. If the person who is harassing you is a member of the organising team, they will not receive differential treatment than any other participant in the handling of the complaint.
We will try to respond as promptly to complaints as we can. These steps will be taken once you make a complaint:
- One or more members of the Event Incidents team will discuss the issue with you.
- They may take notes, with your consent, of what you say.
- One or more members of the Events Incidents team will separately speak with the person(s) against whom the complaint is lodged.
- The process will involve attaining resolution while ensuring safety, dignity and respect for everyone involved.
If a participant engages in harassing behavior, the Response Team may take any action they deem appropriate, up to and including expulsion from all APC spaces during the event, and identification of the participant as a harasser to other APC members or the general public. The Event Incidents team will prioritise marginalised people’s safety over privileged people’s comfort.
Any member of the Event Incidents Team can be contacted with any questions or concerns participants may have throughout the duration of an APC event. Anonymous complaints can be reported to the team on Telegram or submitted via email.
Names and contact information of the Event Incidents Team are as follows:
Resource persons' profiles
Introduction to international advocacy | Paula Martins
Tuesday, 29 June, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Stakeholder mapping & understanding the landscape | Verengai Mabika
Tuesday, 29 June, 2021 [9:00 - 10:30 UTC]
Treaties, instruments & standards: A baseline for international advocacy | Sheetal Kumar
Wednesday, 30 June, 2021 [4:00 - 5:30 UTC]
The UN ecosystem: An overview | Deborah Brown
Wednesday, 30 June, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Engaging with human rights mechanisms at the UN | Sarah Brooks
Wednesday, 30 June, 2021 [9:00 - 10:30 UTC]
Internet governance & digital cooperation | Anriette Esterhuysen
Thursday, 1 July, 2021 [4:00 - 5:30 UTC]
Telecom & internet infrastructure advocacy | Avri Doria
Thursday, 1 July, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Policy advocacy to policy change: LocNet's experience on what works | Carlos Rey Moreno
Thursday, 1 July, 2021 [9:00 - 10:30 UTC]
Integrating gender into the global digital rights agenda | Pooja Badrinath
Friday, 2 July, 2021 [4:00 - 5:30 UTC]
Hacking international advocacy: Strategies for effective engagement | Gayatri Khandhadai
Friday, 2 July, 2021 [6:30 - 8:00 UTC]
Organisers Contact Details
Organisers Contact Details
The Challenge team can be reached at challenge@apc.org!
💥 Online Tools for Workshops and Interactivity
This document is a growing, living list of online platforms and tools we can use in workshops and meeting spaces to aid our facilitation by introducing interactive elements, spark conversation or simply present ideas in more visual or novel ways.
Tool/Platform |
License |
Description |
FOSS (Self Hosted - Already up on APC servers) |
Trello-like kanban board for cards. Supports markdown and is very customizable. |
|
FOSS (not up on APC servers yet) |
Asynchronous participatory decision making and conversation tool |
|
Freemium Proprietary |
Very powerful and flexible online whiteboard and pinboard and more. |
|
Paid Proprietary |
Useful for collecting ideas. Think mro with only stickies. |
|
FOSS (Paid Hosted) |
Very pretty whiteboard, but no uploading of content. It’s under active development. |
|
FOSS (Free hosted) |
Whiteboard with lots of fantastic features, allows annotation of entire websites and uploads. Dated interface with modern powers. |
|
Freemium Proprietary |
||
Freemium Proprietary |
||
Free Online Hosted (FOSS) |
Another mind mapping tool |
|
Free Proprietary |
Super simple livepolling with animations. |
|
Paid |
Very pretty live polls with charts and animations. Everything from wordclouds to graphs. |
|
Free Selfhosted (Coming to APC soon) |
Start live polls in your browser, like mentimeter. More powerful, less pretty. |
🎶 Workshop playlist
Spotify Playlist
https://open.spotify.com/playlist/6kJCQSUJZvxsun5PhZRSVj?si=5c3d93dbff4949e1